Home | Public Area

Document Details - NISO_RP-27-2019_RA21_Identity_Discovery_and_Persistence-public_comment.pdf


Document Details
Share |
Name NISO_RP-27-2019_RA21_Identity_Discovery_and_Persistence-public_comment.pdf (1MB)
Description Recommended Practices for Improved Access to Institutionally-Provided Information Resources: Results from the Resource Access in the 21st Century (RA21) Project

A Recommended Practice of the National Information Standards Organization and the STM Association

Draft for public comment: April 17-May 17, 2019. The comment period has now ended but submitted comments may be viewed.
Document State Draft (A preliminary sketch, outline, or version.)
Group / Folder RA21 / Documents
Submitter By Nettie Lagace on Tuesday, 16 April 2019 01:01pm
Modified By Nettie Lagace on Saturday, 18 May 2019 07:29am
Technical Contact None Selected
Public URL http://groups.niso.org/apps/group_public/document.php?document_id=21376&wg_abbrev=niso-ra21

Comments
Showing 119 of 119 comments
Subject # State Submitter Date Action
Association of Research Libraries Accessibility Comment
0
New
Mary Lee Kennedy
2019-05-17
Address library problems with SAML-based access in practice
0
New
John Mark Ockerbloom
2019-05-17
Association of Research Libraries General Comments
0
New
Mary Lee Kennedy
2019-05-17
Support for user experience improvements
0
New
Adam Chandler
2019-05-17
Use of frames technology is security risk
0
New
Adam Chandler
2019-05-17
“End-to-end traceability” is inconsistent with anonymous access
0
New
Adam Chandler
2019-05-17
Consistent with emerging privacy regulations?
0
New
Adam Chandler
2019-05-17
Data minimization
0
New
Adam Chandler
2019-05-17
Walk-in access
0
New
Adam Chandler
2019-05-17
Authorship bias
0
New
Adam Chandler
2019-05-17
Section comments
0
New
Minitex .
2019-05-17
Forward and introduction
0
New
Minitex .
2019-05-17
Stake holders & representations from non Service Providers
0
New
Ranti Junus
2019-05-17
Clarify the reason for adopting SAML
0
New
Ranti Junus
2019-05-17
Missing Footnote Number 8 on page 13
0
New
Nina McLaughlin
2019-05-17
University of Arizona Libraries General Comments on RA21
0
New
Sarah Shreeves
2019-05-17
Remove loaded language about pirate websites and fraud
0
New
Nina McLaughlin
2019-05-17
Technology is not the problem
0
New
Eric Hellman
2019-05-17
Recommended Practices for Improved Access to Institutionally-Pro
0
New
Amy Bourke-Waite
2019-05-17
Guidance to federation operators
0
New
Nicholas Roy
2019-05-17
Better pseudonymous identifiers exist than eduPersonTargetedID
0
New
Alex Stuart
2019-05-17
Jisc Feedback
0
New
Mark Williams
2019-05-17
Attrbute release
0
New
Andrew Anderson
2019-05-16
Session Timeouts
0
New
Andrew Anderson
2019-05-16
MDUI Logo
0
New
Andrew Anderson
2019-05-16
MDUI DisplayName
0
New
Andrew Anderson
2019-05-16
State of MDUI support by current IdP implementations
0
New
Andrew Anderson
2019-05-16
Displaying Remembered Institutions functionality
0
New
Andrew Anderson
2019-05-16
Use of email address in Streamlined Institution Search
0
New
Andrew Anderson
2019-05-16
Dynamic Access Button Experience
0
New
Andrew Anderson
2019-05-16
NameID and Attribute release for privacy preservation
0
New
Andrew Anderson
2019-05-16
Multilateral Federation Authentication should be out of scope
0
New
Andrew Anderson
2019-05-16
RA21 user testing has been too limited
0
New
Andrew Anderson
2019-05-16
Publisher findings on SAML usage are invalid
0
New
Andrew Anderson
2019-05-16
Adoption of SAML is misrepresented
0
New
Andrew Anderson
2019-05-16
Representation of SAML is overly simplistic
0
New
Andrew Anderson
2019-05-16
Terminology issues in foreword
0
New
Andrew Anderson
2019-05-16
Comments on RA21
0
New
Jennifer Vinopal
2019-05-16
Specific Comments
0
New
Andromeda Yelton
2019-05-16
General Comments
0
New
Andromeda Yelton
2019-05-16
Default button design
0
New
Elias Balafoutis
2019-05-16
Future wok items
0
New
Elias Balafoutis
2019-05-16
Coupling between the persistency service and Button/discovery
0
New
Elias Balafoutis
2019-05-16
Persistence service security & usability
0
New
Elias Balafoutis
2019-05-16
About local storage and privacy
0
New
Elias Balafoutis
2019-05-16
Usability and Security issues with centralized IdP Discovert
0
New
Elias Balafoutis
2019-05-16
UMN Libraries specific comments
0
New
UMN Libraries
2019-05-15
UMN Libraries general comments
0
New
UMN Libraries
2019-05-15
Meaning of "Participating SPs"
0
New
Elias Balafoutis
2019-05-15
Dynamic button provided by the SP
0
New
Elias Balafoutis
2019-05-15
Unmet user expectation
0
New
Elias Balafoutis
2019-05-15
Discovery page requirements for decent experience
0
New
Elias Balafoutis
2019-05-15
Remembering the user's previous choice of IdP is not sufficient
0
New
Elias Balafoutis
2019-05-15
Anonymous access and attribute release consent in practice
0
New
Michael Gibney
2019-05-14
Barriers to Adoption
0
New
Danielle Plumer
2019-05-14
General support for existing comments
0
New
Dale Hendrickson
2019-05-14
Positive single logout needed
0
New
Dale Hendrickson
2019-05-14
Representation on IdP Persistence Service group
0
New
Angela Sidman
2019-05-14
Address Future Work Items now
0
New
Angela Sidman
2019-05-14
Mandate consistent UX for return to library fulfillment services
0
New
Angela Sidman
2019-05-14
Comments and suggestions on several points.
0
New
Paul Butler
2019-05-14
Radical inclusiveness, not yet-another-WAYF (XKCD 927)
0
New
Eric Hellman
2019-05-13
Message to Users when no full text available
0
New
Lizzie Gallagher
2019-05-13
Lack of Librarian Participants in Draft
0
New
Lizzie Gallagher
2019-05-13
General Comments
0
New
Courtney McAllister
2019-05-13
RA Scenario
0
New
Courtney McAllister
2019-05-13
Accessibility Standard
0
New
Courtney McAllister
2019-05-13
Streamlined Institution Search using email
0
New
Lizzie Gallagher
2019-05-13
RA21 must be extended to include
0
New
Tom Cramer
2019-05-13
GEANT CoC misquoted: SPs MUST minimize data
0
New
Tom Cramer
2019-05-13
RA21 should not seek to eliminate support for walk-in use
0
New
Tom Cramer
2019-05-13
Email address as lookup to institution violates security policy
0
New
Tim McGeary
2019-05-13
SSO login cannot happen in frame
0
New
Tim McGeary
2019-05-13
SSO Login must not be in a frame
0
New
Tim McGeary
2019-05-13
Provide implementation specifications
0
New
Andromeda Yelton
2019-05-13
Rent / Own buttons should not be shown to users
0
New
Tim McGeary
2019-05-13
Research and Scholarship Entity Category
0
New
Tim McGeary
2019-05-13
2nd use of eduPersonEntitlement as legacy
0
New
Tim McGeary
2019-05-13
eduPersonEntitlement is legacy, not current
0
New
Tim McGeary
2019-05-13
Handling PII
0
New
Andromeda Yelton
2019-05-13
WAYFless please!
0
New
Helga Perry
2019-05-13
WCAG 2.1 should be the accessibility target
0
New
Tom Cramer
2019-05-11
Inaccurate statement of Stakeholder representation
0
New
Tim McGeary
2019-05-10
Security principles analysis is incomplete
0
New
Tim McGeary
2019-05-10
definition of customer
0
New
Tim McGeary
2019-05-10
Generalise concept of service providers
0
New
Matthew Slowe
2019-05-10
Careful use of words in discussion materials
0
New
Matthew Slowe
2019-05-10
Accessibility - WCGA 2.0 v 2.1
0
New
Laird Barrett
2019-05-10
Use of "institution" and derivatives
0
New
Matthew Slowe
2019-05-10
Hospital/Clinical Access Working Group
0
New
Martin Williamson
2019-05-09
RA21's technical approach is broken by browser privacy features
0
New
Eric Hellman
2019-05-08
RA21 Draft RP session timeout recommendation considered harmful
0
New
Eric Hellman
2019-05-06
Association of attributes with other collected data
0
New
Dorothea Salo
2019-05-06
RA21 RP does not require secure protocols. It should.
0
New
Eric Hellman
2019-05-05
Simplify "Decoupling of access management from the physical net"
0
New
Raoul Teeuwen
2019-05-04
Explain "Multilateral Federated Authentication"
0
New
Raoul Teeuwen
2019-05-04
Delete 'centralized' from 'centralized IdP persistence service'
0
New
Raoul Teeuwen
2019-05-04
Other / Formatting / Textual elements
0
New
Christian Pruvost
2019-05-03
Privacy aspect comment
0
New
Christian Pruvost
2019-05-03
Acknowledgments and References
0
New
Christian Pruvost
2019-05-03
The document is missing an executive summary
0
New
Christian Pruvost
2019-05-03
eduPersonTargetedID has serious security risks
0
New
Nicholas Roy
2019-05-02
Feedback on RA21 recommended practice guidelines
0
New
Jane Charlton
2019-05-02
RA21 feedback
0
New
Katherine Rose
2019-05-02
Support for and expansion on comment #818
0
New
Becky Yoose
2019-04-26
JavaScript disabled on browser scenario?
0
New
Becky Yoose
2019-04-26
Consult with librarians, privacy experts, ethicists.
0
New
Matthew Ruen
2019-04-26
Add insider threat to WAYF threat model
0
New
Dorothea Salo
2019-04-26
Define "minimal request"
0
New
Dorothea Salo
2019-04-26
Limit SP use of "additional attribute" sent by IdP
0
New
Dorothea Salo
2019-04-26
Limit circumstances under which IdPs provide identifiers
0
New
Dorothea Salo
2019-04-26
Explain how "[t]he system will achieve end-to-end traceability"
0
New
Dorothea Salo
2019-04-26
Disallow derived identifiers
0
New
Dorothea Salo
2019-04-26
Support for Comment #00819 - split use cases
0
New
Robert Cartolano
2019-04-22
Split and note privacy implications of use case(s) 1
0
New
John Mark Ockerbloom
2019-04-18
Access for public and unauthenticated users
0
New
James Stephens
2019-04-18
Login and Access via Institution and Discovery
0
New
Michelle Kraft
2019-04-17
Remembering
0
New
Lisa Hinchliffe
2019-04-17
test
0
New
Nettie Lagace
2019-04-16